Strawman argument and did not address my points. You thinking this is "Wattpad level" tells me everything, just because you don't agree with a characters actions doesn't mean the story or the character is poorly developed. Anyways, drop and move on. Go read something like Who Made Me a Princess and be happy with perfect FLs. Yeah, it is a question of what do you tolerate morally in a story. I am pro-FL, but I am not defending her actions nor calling her decisions good here btw. I like my characters morally grey and making decisions that make the story heartwrenching: "I've always agreed with William Faulkner—he said that the human heart in conflict with itself is the only thing worth writing about. I've always taken that as my guiding principle, and the rest is just set dressing." - George RR Martin Rein is in conflict because she both hates and loves Wilhelm excessively, which in turn directly impacts the story and people around her, even her innocent child. She clearly suffers from PTSD and depression, which is a far cry from a "happy ending" in my eyes lol. The treatment she receives in this forum for being cold to a child (not verbal, not physical abuse) is as if she killed him. If the story were condoning her behavior and saying it is good as a lesson then I'd have a problem with it. But with the latest manhwa chapter, you clearly see her regretful and trying to fix her mistake. The story didn't give her a free pass, and I'm sure there will be more development towards her growth in the coming chapters.
Your using words you don't know the meaning of. Did you see peple using "Starman arugments" on the internet and decided it seemed so you started using in evey context Learn the definition of words beforebyou use them or else youll look dumb This is what happnes when you dont read real books bit self insert wish fulfillment noves. Go open a dictionary "She regrets it" wow. So she's sad for a few and you think that's good consequences for her actions? This story has no real consequences her kid forgives her easily as he's just a plot device and we can't have a child being angry at our perfect Mary Sue shittrt. The self inserters would seethe and have melties Like peole are you are already melting down over others saying she a shit mother imagine the reaction if the kid rightfully told her to fuck off She's a deadbeat mother that's abuse. The may ypu keep minimizjng her actions and bringing up whataboutisim is digusting and shameful You keep saying how she is affected yet you spare no thought at how her kid felt at being abandoned and abused This is why I hate self inseters. They go though hoops defending everything there shit MCs do
Don't get me wrong, i know the FL Is a bad mother. But she is not THAT bad , like she's just neglect the child emotions it's pretty sad for the kiddo. But I don't understand what you expect from a character, who literally has not had a breakthrough. She is still trapped in her past. What more consequences is she going to have if she herself is the problem. I am not defending her, but what do you expect from the Fl ? Like it's seem pretty clear that she has no character development from the chap 1, until now where she admits that she hurt her first child.
Does Dietrich ever regain his memories? I'm surprised how tolerant the usual justice warriors are at an innocent man losing all his memories let alone nearly dying just because he was a teacher to a shitty rapist murderer ML that for some reason still gets more love and praises... than a FL who gets a witch hunt for being simply emotionally distant to her child.
That is hilarious because your reply is filled with misspellings. Strawman is literally a basic concept you learn in the first classes of a debate class. Why do you think you know my level of education? Stop attacking me because you hate a character, you need to take a breather. If her kid told her to fuck off, I'd be ok with that lmao. You always make weird assumptions about me understanding a character's actions and you are fixated on admonishing our FL for child neglect, which makes me wonder what's really at play here... I'd recommend you drop this because you clearly are deeply affected by this on a level that is not healthy for you...
Well I completely agree with you @littlepanda It's complex to understand what a mother goes through and what others expect from her. If you are searching for a Rainbow FL with no baggage, this is not the story for you. I don't understand why people bash a character without understanding their complexities and situations. Reinhardt is well.. wrong and not wrong at the same time. But do you even know what child abuse is? It's broad. She just left her kid with his father. She could have just neglected Bill while keeping him with her, and we can say that would have been wrong to some extent. Putting yourself in her place you can just empathize with her... And for a fact she redeemed herself. She accepts that she forwent her child and to accept means half of your sins are absolved...If her child does not forgive that's also not something she can say anything to Because SHE KNOWS what she did
did they change how Rein treats Billroy in the manhwa? I assumed in the novel she ignored him. maybe they transferred all that to bianca?
Bruv just stop arguing, the characters are written in a way in which you can hate them. Hence the fl can be easily hated but that doesn't mean that others can't like them and vice versa. It doesn't matter who took care of the boy, but the mother wasn't there so atleast for that she is at fault. Btw what happens at the end tho? I mean the end of the story?
She still is the Lord of Luden and stays there but she travels to the Imperial capital often to be with Wilhelm , her son also her daughter and her twins. All in all she forgives Wilhelm
i lmao. "just neglect the child emotions", you said. that's already enough to tell me how meaningless you see the abuse and neglect that child went through in your eyes. and no. it's not "pretty sad". it's actually really really frckn sad and traumatizing for a kid to be emotionally neglected by their parents. irl, the least and healthiest thing she can do (if she doesn't want to take care of the child in every aspect) is to give the child to a couple who really want to have a child but can't. but obviously, that didn't happen in the story, since the kid is just a plot device for the story.
With the last chapter, I'm just going to reiterate how amazing this story and same for the FL. For once we got a FL who values her family - her father and Dietrich, and doesn't betray them for some dixk like readers want her to (well we'll see how it goes in future, but at least she doesn't do it as soon as possible which I give her credit for). And no, she's not a monster for being emotionally distant to a rape child who was still well taken care of otherwise, not to mention she treats him with love now. She's resentful, spiteful and imperfect but she's still a human with feelings. Besides I love how the typical trope of a regressed FL who manipulates everyone with her schemes got turned around in this story. A breath of fresh air. All in all, it's very well written for it's genre of toxic romance, and main characters aren't Mary Sues and Princes on a White horse or some typical tsunderes. Honestly, best regressor manhwa I ever read. Though obviously it's not for people expecting a stereotypical self insert Mary Sue-2nd coming of Jesus and her Romeo.